I promised you all a post on congregational church polity. So, here it is. The phrase “congregational church polity” simply means that the congregation (local church) governs itself. This has been the normal or usual approach to church governance in the SBC. In fact, when I began in ministry 58 years ago, all the SBC churches I knew about used the congregational approach. They did this by means of church business meetings. The frequency of the business meetings varied. Some churches had monthly business meetings, while others met quarterly. I knew one church that met annually to conduct its business.
What is the biblical basis for congregational polity? When I teach seminary students about church polity, I point them to Acts 6:1-6–.
“Now in these days when the disciples were increasing in number, a complaint by the Hellenists[a] arose against the Hebrews because their widows were being neglected in the daily distribution. 2 And the twelve summoned the full number of the disciples and said, “It is not right that we should give up preaching the word of God to serve tables. 3 Therefore, brothers,[ pick out from among you seven men of good repute, full of the Spirit and of wisdom, whom we will appoint to this duty. 4 But we will devote ourselves to prayer and to the ministry of the word.” 5 And what they said pleased the whole gathering, and they chose Stephen, a man full of faith and of the Holy Spirit, and Philip, and Prochorus, and Nicanor, and Timon, and Parmenas, and Nicolaus, a proselyte of Antioch. 6 These they set before the apostles, and they prayed and laid their hands on them.”
Notice the sequence of events narrated here. The apostles encountered a problem in the Jerusalem church. Then, they proposed a solution to the congregation. The church approved their recommendation, and the church members chose seven men to administer the church’s benevolence ministry. This is a clear example of congregational polity at work.
When I started in ministry, Herschel Hobbs was “Mr. Southern Baptist.” He earned a PhD in New Testament at Southern Baptist Seminary, studying under A. T. Robertson. He went on to pastor the First Baptist Church of Oklahoma City for more than thirty years, and he was the preacher on “The Baptist Hour” for more than 30 years. He served as president of the SBC, and he served as chairman of the SBC committee that produced the 1963 Statement of Faith and Message. After the SBC approved that statement of faith, Hobbs wrote a book, “What Baptists Believe,” in which he explained the doctrines included in the statement. This is what he wrote about church polity:
“The New Testament pattern is that of the congregation [ruling itself]. The congregation elected deacons (Acts 6:1-6), sent forth missionaries (Acts 13:1-3), administered discipline (Matt 18:7), expelled members (1 Cor 5:4-5), and received members (2 Cor 2:5-8). While at times the local church worked through committees (Acts 15:6-21), the local authority resided in the congregation (Acts 15:22ff.). The apostles advised and exhorted the churches, but each church determined its own course of conduct (1 Cor 16:1-7; 2 Cor 2:5-8; 2 Cor 8).” (p. 79)
What are the advantages of congregational polity? Two advantages readily come to mind. First, it is biblical. Of course, that is essential. The second is that congregational polity is familiar. For most older church members, this is the only approach to polity they have ever known.
What are the disadvantages? One is the difficulty in educating the members about decisions that need to be made. The larger the church, the harder it is to inform the members. Think of it this way. In New England, many villages rule themselves by means of town meetings. That works fine in a village, but it would be impossible to govern Boston, Massachusetts, using the town meeting approach. Recently, Second Baptist Church of Houston experienced a serious dispute over changes to its constitution and bylaws. Even though the church has thousands of members, only a few hundred attended the business meeting to vote on the changes. The changes were approved at the business meeting, but later a group of members claimed they were not informed, or sufficiently informed, about the changes. Another disadvantage is that church members do not always conduct themselves properly in business meetings. All long-time Southern Baptists have experienced, or at least heard about, a business meeting that became quite heated. Ideally, members would pray to know the mind of Christ about their church’s business and also conduct themselves in a Christ-like manner, but, sadly, that is not always true. A third disadvantage is that the congregational approach is slow and unwieldy. The argument is that in our rapidly changing culture, churches need to be more nimble in their decision-making process.
So, which is better? Congregational polity or elder polity? I’m sure advocates for the elder-led approach would insist their favored approach is also congregational. After all, the church members elect the elders (usually). Personally, I prefer the congregational approach because I’m old, and the congregational approach is what I know. Still, many churches are adopting the elder polity. Recently, my friend and former student, Dr. Chuck Lawless, Vice-President at Southeastern Baptist Seminary, wrote on his blog that he now favors the elder polity. He’s really smart, so maybe I should agree with him.
Well, Voices readers, what do you think?
P.S. If you seek more support for congregational polity, I can recommend Stanton Norman’s book, “The Baptist Way,” and John Hammett’s book, “Biblical Foundations for Baptist Churches.”